People's Choice Restaurant East Orange
People's Choice Restaurant Logo

People's Choice Restaurant

4.21146 reviews

Nestled on Central Ave in East Orange, People's Choice Restaurant serves authentic Caribbean cuisine. It's a local gem known for its vibrant dishes and friendly atmosphere. The restaurant offers takeout and seating options, catering to all needs. From lunch to late-night dinners, this spot has something for everyone.

The ambiance is warm, perfect for casual dining or a quick bite. You can smell the spices wafting from the kitchen, a prelude to a truly delightful meal. Whether enjoying a solo meal or gathering with friends, it's a welcoming environment where everyone feels at home.

Expect to find hearty portions at reasonable prices. With popular dishes like jerk chicken and curried goat, there's a reason this place is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. It's not just a meal; it's an experience that reflects the heart of Caribbean culture.

About

East Orange has a rich history reflected in its vibrant cultures, including a love for Caribbean flavors. People's Choice Restaurant combines traditional recipes with fresh ingredients. The restaurant’s story begins with a passion for sharing home-style Jamaican cooking with the community.

This location has welcomed patrons for years, becoming a staple for anyone craving Caribbean comfort food. It’s a place where grandparents introduce their grandchildren to iconic dishes, fostering a sense of community and continuity in flavors.

Walking in, you might notice a variety of patrons—families, friends, and solo diners. Everyone comes together under one roof, united by a shared love for delicious, hearty meals. The restaurant embodies the spirit of East Orange while serving dishes that have roots far and wide.

Get in Touch

63 Central Ave, East Orange, NJ 07018, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-21:00
  • Tuesday 11:00-21:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-21:00
  • Thursday 11:00-21:00
  • Friday 11:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-21:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"I've eaten here before the food taste okay, the service was good... nice, polite and kind of fast. The down side for me was I wanted to order ahead so I googled the restaurant to check pricing and get the number. When I called to place my order something said double check the price and it was a $10 difference from what the online price was. Not sure why that is, but I haven't been back since."

- Judy A.

"The curry goat platter was amazing! Fresh food and huge portions. Definitely coming back."

- Vishal B.

"The only reason why I did not give 5 stars is because of the oil at the bottom of the food. Otherwise, the flavor is incredible as usual. Back 8/9/21 and the curry was great."

- Anita -.

"This place was really good I was new from Ohio here and the only bad part was if you didn't know what you want GET OUT THE WAY ! the guy at the front seemed like he was impatient but we got stew chicken , rice and peas salad and cabbage , it was really good we got a large and a beef pattie you can tell it was made from scratch , I CANT WAIT TO COME BACK . My husband loves island food , and I really enjoyed it ."

- Jasmin L.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visit People's Choice for its inviting atmosphere and mouthwatering food. The extensive menu boasts dishes that will satisfy anyone's craving. Enjoy curried goat blended with spices, or opt for brown stew chicken served with rice and peas—a must-try!

Timing your visit can enhance your experience. Lunchtime offers a more relaxed vibe, while dinner time can be bustling. For the best experience, arrive early. Parking is available, making access easy. Don’t rush your meal; the flavors deserve attention.

Pay attention as well to their vegan options. The restaurant prides itself in catering to vegetarians, a rarity in many Caribbean spots. Their small shared plates also encourage sampling multiple dishes. It's both fun and flavorful, making the dining experience lively and engaging.

Most Liked things

Diners rave about the flavorful curried goat. It’s rich and satisfying, with a perfect blend of spices. The vibe is casual and welcoming, making even first-time visitors feel like family. Portions are generous, promising value for your money.

Service is generally quick, ensuring that you won't wait long to savor your meal. The cocktails and juices add a refreshing touch to your dining experience, especially after enjoying a spicy dish. It's this combination of taste and atmosphere that keeps people coming back.

The restaurant embraces a strong community spirit. Regular customers often see familiar faces, fostering camaraderie among diners. This sense of belonging enhances any visit, making meals here memorable.

Most Disliked things

Some diners notice inconsistencies in pricing, especially when ordering ahead. This can be frustrating for those who like to plan their meals. It's best to clarify prices by calling the restaurant directly.

Occasionally, service may seem rushed during peak hours. Busy times can create an atmosphere where customers feel pressured. A slower pace might create a more relaxed dining experience, allowing patrons to fully enjoy their meals.

Lastly, some diners mention they wish there were more desserts on offer. While the existing options like carrot and chocolate cake are delightful, more variety could enhance the sweet end to a meal.

FAQ

What dishes should I try at People's Choice Restaurant?

Try the Curried Goat or Barbeque Chicken. The Brown Stew Chicken is a favorite too. Don't miss the Patties, especially the Spinach & Cheese.

What is the average price range for meals here?

Most dishes range from $10 to $20. Expect to spend about $11 for a meal. It's affordable, especially given the generous portions.

Is there an option for vegetarians?

Yes, the menu includes dishes suitable for vegetarians. Try the Vegetable Patties or some of the delicious Roti options.

Can I dine here with children?

Absolutely! The restaurant is family-friendly. There are options for kids and the atmosphere is relaxed.